Universal Healthcare and Why It’s Impossible NOT to Support It!

2008 May 22
by Yvette

I’m going to try getting back into…the groove. Ha. As well as trying to improve my earlier writing style. Reading back, my writing seems more like rants with little too back them up, and nothing interesting on new issues. It’s been a while since I’ve written like this, so I’ll probably sound like an idiot, but here goes. Hopefully I haven’t written something similar before. I still haven’t gone through everything.

An argument for universal, socialized healthcare.

America was founded on a central idea: the rights of the people would be protected by the government. Our Bill of Rights guarantees the protection of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. One can argue endlessly about liberty and the pursuit of happiness, but every human being’s right to life is undeniable.

In America today, millions of impoverished people are being denied their right to live because they cannot pay for health insurance, or their insurance companies deny them care. There is no reason to keep universal healthcare from reaching the people who need it. Yes, it may result in higher taxes. Yes, it may be harder to sustain. Are we a nation who cannot even make such necessary and easy sacrifices to save lives? There is no reason that wealth should ever affect one’s right to live. There are those who would argue that it is the person’s own fault for not seizing opportunities to become wealthy. Yet many of these people have not had the opportunity to become wealthy–children born into poor families, for example, should never have to die for their parent’s mistakes. And the few who can afford healthcare on their own, around 1% of our population, are gaining more and more — undeserved — wealth through inheritance, extortion, outsourcing, and other dishonest means, yet those born into poverty through no fault of their own suffer and die?

I’ll give an example of an infant death due to our insurance system, one that frankly sickens me.

In the movie Sicko by Michael Moore (don’t shoot me), a lower class black woman tells the story of how her infant daughter had stopped breathing and had to be rushed to the hospital. However, her insurance provider refused to pay for treatment if her daughter was treated at that hospital. Instead, they wanted her to drive her dying daughter to a distant hospital where they would pay for it. The hospital that they were already at refused to treat the daughter, and the infant girl soon died.

How can people support a system that kills their fellow citizens for being too poor to afford insurance? And as many know, even having insurance is not enough. If our country ever wants to call itself humane or have any pride, we need universal, free healthcare. Anything else is murder.

6 Responses leave one →
  1. 2008 May 23
    Yeti permalink

    I personally have a gigantic problem with the insurance system – but it is not the government’s problem to solve.

    What i dont get is if insurance works like a bet, the only way insurance companies make money is off of people who pay more than they use. So, if people saved, they wouldn’t need insurance. Now, the government could have a program where they pay for emergencies and people like that poor baby. But consider this!

    Sweden, a country which pays for all the health expenses of it’s citezins (totally spelled that wrong) has some of the highest happiness ratings in the world. But, this comes coupled with 60% of the national budget being spent on healthcare, an immigration system which cannot legally turn back thousands of middle eastern refugees who collect in the lowest tax brackets and suck the system out, and a large amount of Neo-Nazi groups that arise from the influx of immigrants.

    So, i ask you three questions:

    1) Where will this money come from? Which programs should be canceled for this?

    2) Is there a solution to the current situation that does not involve socializing healthcare?

    3) Did my arguement make any sense. I realize in retrospect that i basically connected socialized healthcare to the rise of neo-nazis. Trust me that wasnt the intention

  2. 2008 May 23
    Playstation Girl permalink

    Yes it did :)

    While a socialized healthcare system would cost alot of money, countries like England and Canada and France are doing just fine. Consider that we spend most of our country’s money on military spending. We spend more money killing people than keeping people alive.

    Another solution I suppose would be to greatly reduce taxes on the poor so they can more likely afford healthcare, and get rid of this ridiculous ‘trickle-down’ theory that only widens the gap between the rich and the poor.

    BTW, your username is my real life nickname. Creepy. o_o;

  3. 2008 May 23
    yeti permalink

    England and France are having similar problems with immigration. remember all the riots in paris over immigration? A big reason these people come to these countries is the healthcare. Because of the fragile nature of the healthcare system, it would need to be safe from a draining factor, like poor immigrants. I think immigrants are great, as I’m second generation myself, but this sort of system attracts people who are planning on taking full advantage. It’s kind of silly when Americans today say Mexicans are freeloading off the country now, but they wouldn’t far off if there was an amnesty program for poor immigrants COUPLED with Universal Healthcare.

    I like your solution non-socialized solution. It makes for a more friendly environment for poor people to succeed.

    The military budget’s a little swollen right now, there’s no arguing that. I personally think the money would be better spent on education/internal improvements.

  4. 2008 June 19
    Anonymous permalink

    I haven’t seen Sicko so I cannot comment directly on the story about the little girl. However, I do know that hospital cannot refuse to treat ER patient out of fear of nonpayment.

  5. 2008 June 21
    Tessa Enright permalink

    well said. i was very angry after i viewed this film.

    i was uninsured for about five years after i turned 18. my family and i could not afford health care. i went on AHCCCS insurance and was turned down for getting a wisdom tooth extraction, even when i was having excruciating pain and it was damaging my other teeth. they said the surgery was unnecessary.

    now i am living in germany and happily insured. i got my wisdom teeth out last month (finally!) for free.

    it makes me sad that my family works so hard for lousy health insurance. if they become ill, they will go broke.

    it is unfair that our government perpetuates these ideas about socialized medicine being a bad thing. i’m sure every uninsured person would be happy to give up a little more of their paycheck in order to be taken care of. why can’t the more fortunate people do the same?

  6. 2009 September 23
    Contact permalink

    I’d like to ask you a favor re: a comment I left on this post, but cannot find a contact link. I was hoping you could delete it for me please! Your help would be greatly appreciated.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS